I finally got around to watching the latest Harry Potter movie – Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. I’m not a huge fan of the series, and I have only read the first book. However while watching this movie I noticed a particular section of the movie that paralleled our public educational system, especially here in Michigan.
Early in the movie (about 35 minutes in), the new professor (brought in from the government – the “ministry of magic”) announces that everyone will be taking the “Ordinary Wizarding Level examinations”, aka the OWLs. The format of the course that Harry and his classmates undertake is explained as a “carefully structured, ministy (government) approved” curriculum. When the students question this new method of learning their defense of the dark arts spells and whatnot, the professor replies that “it is the view of the ministry (government) that a theoretical understanding of the material is sufficient enough to get you through your examinations, (and here comes my favorite part) which is what school is all about!”
Harry argues, “but how is theory supposed to prepare us for what’s out there?” BINGO.
I can’t help but see this segment as a direct observation of our own school systems. The Michigan Merit Exam (formerly the MEAP test) has determined the material that is taught in the classroom and even the method it is taught. Teachers are required to cover the MME material first before discussing anything else, but because of the strong ties state funding has with the students’ exam results, most of the time only exam material is being taught – all theoretical and basic information. Like Harry points out in the movie, there is very little practical knowlege bestowed as a result of “teaching the tests”, nothing about finding a job, getting into college, managing finances, and other ‘real-world’ abilities.
There is even talk of moving to a national standardized test, similar to the ACT, in order to “determine” what students should know before graduation. *SPOILER ALERT* The OWLs didn’t work out at Hogwarts, and they don’t seem to be here in Michigan.